Josh Kendall

Kendall Soundoff: Why I left Clowney off my first-team ballot

jkendall@thestate.comDecember 9, 2013 

South Carolina defensive end Jadeveon Clowney

KIM KIM FOSTER-TOBIN — kkfoster@thestate.com

  • KENDALL’S BALLOT

    FIRST-TEAM OFFENSE

    WR Mike Evans, Texas A&M

    WR Jordan Matthews, Vanderbilt

    L Justin Britt, Missouri

    L Cyrus Kouandjio, Alabama

    L Jake Matthews, Texas A&M

    L Gabe Jackson, Mississippi State

    C Travis Swanson, Arkansas

    TE Arthur Lynch, Georgia

    QB Johnny Manziel, Texas A&M

    RB Tre Mason, Auburn

    RB Jeremy Hill, LSU

    PK Marshall Morgan, Georgia

    All-Purpose Nick Marshall, Auburn

    FIRST-TEAM DEFENSE

    E/LB Michael Sam, Missouri

    E Dee Ford, Auburn

    T/NT Kelcy Quarles, USC

    T/E Dante Fowler, Florida

    LB C.J. Mosley, Alabama

    LB Ramik Wilson, Georgia

    LB Serderius Bryant, Ole Miss

    CB Victor Hampton, USC

    CB Vernon Hargreaves, Florida

    S Ha-Ha Clinton-Dix, Alabama

    S Kenny Ladler, Vanderbilt

    P Michael Palardy, Tennessee

    OFFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR

    Tre Mason, Auburn

    DEFENSIVE PLAYER OF THE YEAR

    Michael Sam, Missouri

    COACH OF THE YEAR

    Gary Pinkel, Missouri

    FRESHMAN OF THE YEAR

    Alex Collins, Arkansas

The Associated Press released its All-SEC team on Monday, and two Gamecocks cracked the first unit: defensive tackle Kelcy Quarles and defensive end Jadeveon Clowney. Running back Mike Davis, cornerback Victor Hampton and spur Sharrod Golightly made the second team.

I was one of 14 voters for the team, and I’ve included my ballot below. A quick word on the format of the vote: Each voter was asked to select a first-team and nothing more. The second-team and honorable mentions were filled out by using the players who got first-team votes but fell short of enough to make that team.

I voted for Quarles and Hampton on my first team, and at this point, I’m sure you’re thinking, “What about Mike Davis?” and “Do you remember that Jadeveon Clowney plays for South Carolina?” so I’ll try to address those questions here.

Davis had a great season, and I would have had a much tougher decision had he not closed so slowly, averaging 2.7 yards per carry in the final three games of the year. Auburn’s Tre Mason and LSU’s Jeremy Hill deserve the top two spots at running back, but Davis certainly will be a strong candidate for the preseason team next fall.

On Clowney, I agree that his disruption has influenced games even when his statistics have not, but I don’t think that has equaled the years Missouri’s Michael Sam and Auburn’s Dee Ford had.

And, while you may not have thought about this question, I’ll suggest it: “What about Connor Shaw?” Steve Spurrier suggested Shaw could even be a Heisman Trophy candidate so why not an All-SEC candidate? In my mind, at least, Shaw was definitely an All-SEC candidate, and the quarterback vote was the hardest for me on this ballot. I considered Shaw, and his 21 touchdowns passes and one interception, for a long time. In the end, though, Johnny Manziel’s staggering numbers were just too much for me to ignore. As important as Shaw is to the Gamecocks, can you imagine the Aggies without Manziel?

On the non-Gamecock front, a couple things struck me during the voting. The first was, what happened to all the linebackers in the SEC? The first-team released Monday are the three players I voted for — Alabama’s C.J. Mosley, Georgia’s Ramik Wilson and Tennessee’s A.J. Johnson — but I’m not going to try to convince anyone that Wilson and Johnson are elite players. Mosley is a stud, no question, but I wonder how much of the league’s defensive struggles this year can be traced to linebacker play that doesn’t quite measure up to previous years.

The second thing was, where are all the superstar freshmen? I voted for Arkansas’ Alex Collins, and he’s a really good player, but, again, it’s not like he had a fantastic season. It seems like in previous years, there were two or three freshman at least who made you think, ‘Wow, that guy had a great year.’ This year, Collins was more like a fallback position. It’s early to suggest this means other conferences might start closing the gap on the SEC, but it’s worth watching to see if it becomes a trend.

Go Gamecocks is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service